StudySmarter - The all-in-one study app.
4.8 • +11k Ratings
More than 3 Million Downloads
Free
The main political parties today are the Republicans and the Democrats. But red vs. blue wasn't always the dividing line in America: shortly after gaining independence in 1783, debates about how the United States should run fell along the federalist vs. antifederalist line.
The main division in their ideas boiled down to the relationship between the state governments and the federal government.Federalists believed that the United States should form a strong central government to unite the states, while antifederalists believed that the states should maintain the same level of power and authority with only a weak central government.
For their part, federalists believed that the federal government's policies and laws should take precedence over state laws. They also thought the country needed a strong executive in the form of a president along withchecks and balanceson each of the branches to make sure no entity (the executive, legislative, or judcicial branch) had too much power.
On the other hand, antifederalists believed that states needed to have more power than the central government in order to preserve rights. They feared that a strong central government would become powerful and abusive, like King George III and Parliament had. They also feared that the presidency would become monarichal over time.
Just as today's political parties evolved out of decades of history, the roots of the debate between federalism and antifederalism went back much farther than the Revolutionary War.
The famous French political theorist Alexis de Tocqueville once said: “[i]n America . . . it may be said that the township was organized before the county, the county before the state, the state before the union.”
Indeed, the American colonies were settled at separate times by separate groups of people, mostly by the British. The first colonies were settled in the 17th century.By 1723, all 13 colonies had been founded。Because of this history, even though most of their ancestors had come from England, they didn't have a common identity as a country, and instead identified more with their respective colonies. The main thing they had in common was their frustrations with England.
Tensions between the American colonies and the British crown grew in the 1750s and 1760s due to heavy taxation by the British. By 1776, theSecond Continental Congressissued the Declaration of Independence and the war officially started. Eventually, the new country won independence and signed a peace treaty with England in 1783.
When the colonies declared war on England, they still did not have a central government. In between making war decisions, theSecond Continental Congressmanaged to pass theArticles of Confederationin 1781.
AConfederationis a government system where independent states or countries decide to band together with some sort of central government. The central government usually helps provide some coordination, is made up of representatives from each member state, and has less authority or power than the member states.
TheArticles of Confederationwere the first government structure. The Articles named the country the United States of America and gave Congress the authority to do things like declare war, but not to tax the states.
尽管美国设法赢得Revolutionary War, the young country faced significant struggles under the Articles ofConfederation。Congress had no money and states stopped sending it in as they focused on their own debts. Soldiers who fought in the war fell into debt because Congress couldn't afford to pay them, leading some to rebel. Many representatives stopped bothering to show up to Congress voting sessions and states started fighting about borders, commerce, and westward expansion.
The United States was on shaky ground because of the problems in theArticles of Confederation。In 1787, the representatives came together for a Constitutional Convention to develop a new government framework. The Convention succeeded in reaching a compromise that people were willing to sign. However, it came with some intense debates between the federalists and antifederalists over a few key issues.
TheSupremacy Clausein the Constitution reads:
This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.
This clause has been interpreted to mean that if there are any conflicts between the state and federal law, then the federal law will take precedence.
This raised alarm bells for antifederalists. They felt that giving the federal government the Constitutional authority to be the supreme law of the land would threaten states' rights and create a tyrannical federal government. In the end, the federalists won, and theSupremacy Clauseremained in the Constitution.
TheCommerce Clausesays that:
[The Congress shall have Power . . . ] To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes;
This clause came directly out of the mess created by theArticles of Confederation。Before the Constitution, Congress didn't have the authority to regulate interstate commerce, which led to huge problems between the states over trade disputes.
While everyone agreed that something had to be done, antifederalists feared that the clause left it too open to interpretation. For example, who gets to decide what "commerce" means? Does it include manufacturing or just the exchange of goods?
In the end, the federalists won out and theCommerce Clausewas included in the Constitution.
Slavery was an important debate during the Constitutional Convention. Many states depended on enslaved labor for their economy. Pro-slavery delegates feared that the Commerce Clause could lead to the federal government claiming the authority to regulate (and abolish) slavery, so one reason for pushing for states' rights was to make sure that they could continue practicing slavery.
Another clause that gave antifederalists pause was the "Necessary and Proper Clause。" The clause says that Congress has the power to:
让所有的法律是必要的和适当的for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.
Most of Article 1 in the Constitution lists out specific powers (called Enumerated or Delineated Powers. See Enumerated and Implied Powers). For example, it gives Congress the power to create a national currency, provide common defense, and declare war.
The federalists believed that over time, the needs of the country might change, and some of the provisions they drafted might not cover all of the duties that Congress would need to fulfill. So, they thought the "Necessary and Proper Clause" was a good compromise: it would allow Congress to pass laws needed to fulfill its other duties (called Implied Powers) while still tying its authority to the Constitution. While the antifederalists expressed concern that this clause could give the federal government too much power, the clause still stayed in the Constitution.
The federalists had a few wins with clauses in the Constitution, but the antifederalists put their foot down when it came to including a Bill of Rights.The antifederalists said that without a Bill of Rights, the federal government could easily trample on citizens' rights.The federalists said that a Bill of Rights wasn't necessary and that listing out rights could actually be bad for individual freedom because it could imply that any rights not specifically listed weren't protected by the Constitution.
While they didn't come to a conclusion during the Constitutional Convention, the antifederalists succeeded in convincing several states to ratify the Constitution only if a Bill of Rights was added. In 1791, Congress passed the Bill of Rights, which included the first 10 Amendments to the Constitution.
The Tenth Amendment clarified that any powers not specifically given to the federal government would be reserved for states (called reserved powers).
After Congress passed its version of the Constitution in 1787, the document still had to be ratified by 9 of the 13 states before it could become law (which it eventually did, in 1789).
The time in between Congress's passage and state ratification provided the opportunity for both the federalists and antifederalists to make their case to the states. One key state that was still up in the air was New York. Politicians began making arguments in New York newspapers (which were then spread throughout the country) to persuade them to vote for or against the Constitution.
Someone under the pen name of "Brutus" wrote an essay published in New York arguing against the Constitution. Even though several others used different pen names to publish their antifederalist essays, the series of essays became known asBrutus Papers。他们支持反联邦主义者的观点pushed for New York to reject the Constitution. They specifically called out the concerns over theSupremacy Clause,Necessary and Proper Clause, Congress's authority to tax, and the lack of a Bill of Rights (with particular attention to protections for the rights of the accused).
The other authors (and their pen names) are believed to be George Clinton, Governor of New York (Cato), Patrick Henry, Samuel Bryan (Centinel), Richard Henry Lee (The Federal Farmer), and Robert Yates (Brutus)
When the federalist camp saw the Brutus papers published in the paper, they knew they had to respond or risk losing New York's support for the Constitution. Their collection of published essays became known asThe Federalist Papers。The Federalist Papers were written under the pen name "Publius." Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay are credited with writing the 85 Federalist Papers.
The Federalist Papersprovided a comprehensive rebuttal to each point brought up in the Brutus papers. Even after the Brutus papers stopped being published, the Federalist Papers (at that point, mostly written by Alexander Hamilton) continued in a flurry. The essays argued that the country was the perfect size for a Republic, the system ofchecks and balancesand branched government would prevent the government from growing too powerful, the country need a strong executive to lead it (the president), and an independent Supreme Court would keep the power of Congress and the President in check.
The debate between the federalists and antifederalists centered on whether the federal government or state governments should have more power.
联邦党人认为,年轻的中国东北eded to have a strong central government to unite the states and provide leadership. They felt that the system of checks and balances would prevent it from growing too powerful or tyrannical.
联邦党人认为,年轻的中国东北eded to have a strong central government to unite the states and provide leadership, while the Antifederalists believed that a strong central government could oppress citizens similar to what happened under British rule.
The main difference between the Federalists and Antifederalists was that the Federalists pushed for a Constitution that created a strong central government, while the Antifederalists opposed the Constitution and felt that the state governments needed to be in charge.
联邦党人认为,年轻的中国东北eded to have a strong central government to unite the states and provide leadership. They supported a unitary executive and a president who could make executive decisions. They argued that the Supreme Court would help restrain the president's power.
of the users don't pass the Federalist vs Anti Federalist quiz! Will you pass the quiz?
Start QuizBe perfectly prepared on time with an individual plan.
Test your knowledge with gamified quizzes.
Create and find flashcards in record time.
Create beautiful notes faster than ever before.
Have all your study materials in one place.
Upload unlimited documents and save them online.
Identify your study strength and weaknesses.
Set individual study goals and earn points reaching them.
Stop procrastinating with our study reminders.
Earn points, unlock badges and level up while studying.
Create flashcards in notes completely automatically.
Create the most beautiful study materials using our templates.
Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.